menu-toggle Created with Sketch.
Live

Early Signing Period Will Change College Football Recruiting

Embed
<iframe src="https://campusinsiders.com/videos/gxY2x5ODE6yw8KRLZW7nifGEnez7S-bT/?video-embed=1" width="640" height="360" style="border:0"></iframe>

The NCAA will vote on a proposal for an early signing period in December, which will permanently affect college football recruiting.


The evolution of college football recruiting is undeniable.

It used to be simple: get scouted, get offered, commit and sign. Boom — end of recruitment.

But now, we live in an era where butt-dialing a recruit can lead to a NCAA violation. It’s the same atmosphere in which coaches can sleep over at a prospect’s house or take a kid’s family go-karting.

While it’ll still be filled with crazy stories like a player’s mom running off with his National Letter of Intent in fear of her baby boy moving away from home (see: Alex Collins), the progression of the recruiting cycle will look very different quite soon.

The NCAA will move forward with a new early signing period to be set in December, according to Football Scoop. The 2018 recruiting class could be the first group to experience it.

The rate and manner in which prospects and coaches operate will be significantly altered.

Butch Dill-USA TODAY Sports

The Race To Commit

We see it plenty: Coaches will tell recruits how much they want them to come and play at their respective universities, simultaneously nudging those same players toward a commitment due to the risk of someone else filling the vacancy. It happens all the time. A kid will like the school, the staff and the sales pitch. He’ll then rush his commitment, which has become more of an insurance plan to save a seat in class, without firmly knowing whether the program is a good fit.

This could intensify with a December signing period. It’s basic supply and demand. If Alabama offers five 4-star running backs but can only take two of them in the cycle, well, that will put pressure on those five tailbacks to decide if their routes toward the future include a stop in Tuscaloosa. More importantly, they have to make that decision before their senior seasons are over.

And, because their hands will be forced, we could see an increase in transfers. A player will rush the process and end up signing up for the wrong situation all because he bought into what the coaches were telling him, and he didn’t want to miss out on an opportunity.

The Coaching Carousel

Consider that the bulk of coaching carousel moves transpire after the season is finished. What happens to the player set to begin his college career in Berkley as a Golden Bear, only to find out his future head coach has been fired a week into the new year? Or how about the pocket passer whose new head coach wants to run a spread offense instead of a pro-style scheme?

Those players should be allowed to transfer without having to sit out an entire season. You could argue that the December signing period would discourage players from committing to coaches instead of schools, but that’s dabbling in idealism. Recruits will forever base their decisions, first and foremost, on the coaches making their pitches.

We may see more coaches get fired mid-season because of the “why wait” mentality and the hope of salvaging a recruiting class. It may also force athletic directors to bite their tongues — then the bullet — and hold on to their respective head coaches. When Mark Richt was fired by Georgia, the Bulldogs were in serious danger of losing Jacob Eason’s commitment. He flirted with Florida. He thought about Miami. And if it were anyone but Kirby Smart calling the shots in Athens, there’s a chance Eason wouldn’t be a Bulldog today. Believe it or not, recruiting plays a huge role in a coach’s job security.

Melina Vastola-USA TODAY Sports

The Drama

Whether it’s Cece Jefferson holding out on sending his NLI, Cyrus Kouandijo flipping to Alabama from Auburn after publicly committing to the Tigers, or DeSean Jackson surprising everyone and choosing Cal over USC, we love the drama. And while many claim to hate it, following the recruiting narratives is a guilty pleasure of many college football fans. It’s fun. It’s exciting. Sure, it has its annoying moments, but it’s exhilarating at its peak.

An early signing period could turn college football recruiting into The Office after Michael Scott left — still good, but never the same. Dalvin Cook had Gators fans hyped about the future he’d have in The Swamp. Then he flipped to Florida State right before the new year, and everything changed. If Cook’s process was sped up, maybe he’s breaking records in Gainesville instead of Tallahassee. Maybe he would have followed the same path and become a ‘Nole, though the odds are much slimmer.

While we don’t actually know what recruiting will look like one, three, or five years from now, rest assured that an early signing period will certainly alter the way it runs now.

MORE: 4-Star WR Xavier Williams Announces College Commitment

Related Posts

Hoops Highlights

  • Video
  • February 26, 2017
  • Campus Insiders

Middle Tennessee Clinches C-USA Title Outright

Middle Tennessee survived UAB to clinch the Conference USA regular season championship outright with a game-winning jump shot from JaCorey Williams with 4.4 seconds remaining. It’s the Blue Raiders’ first C-USA regular season title.

Live Events

All times are Eastern Time Zone.

Live Schedule

All times are Eastern Time Zone.
Clear Filters
Monday, February 27, 2017
TimeET Title Category Network
12:00 pm Mountain West Network
2:30 pm Basketball (W) Mountain West Network
2:45 pm Basketball (M) Mountain West Network
3:00 pm Ice Hockey (M) Mountain West Network
4:00 pm Baseball TheW.TV
9:00 pm Baseball TheW.TV
Tuesday, February 28, 2017
TimeET Title Category Network
5:00 pm Baseball TheW.TV
7:00 pm Lacrosse (M) Patriot League Network
7:00 pm Basketball (M) Patriot League Network
7:30 pm Basketball (M) Patriot League Network
9:00 pm Baseball TheW.TV
9:00 pm
UNLV at Utah State
Basketball (W)
Basketball (W) Mountain West Network
9:00 pm Baseball Mountain West Network
9:30 pm Basketball (W) Mountain West Network
10:00 pm Basketball (M) Mountain West Network
Wednesday, March 1, 2017
TimeET Title Category Network
12:15 am Basketball (M) Mountain West Network
12:15 am Basketball (M) Mountain West Network
3:00 pm Lacrosse (W) Patriot League Network
4:00 pm Baseball TheW.TV
5:00 pm Baseball Mountain West Network
7:00 pm Basketball (W) Patriot League Network
7:00 pm
Colgate at Lehigh
Basketball (W)
Basketball (W) Patriot League Network
7:00 pm
American at Navy
Basketball (W)
Basketball (W) Patriot League Network
7:05 pm Basketball (W) Patriot League Network
9:00 pm Basketball (M) Mountain West Network
Thursday, March 2, 2017
TimeET Title Category Network
12:15 am Mountain West Network
12:15 am Mountain West Network
3:00 pm Basketball (W) TheW.TV
5:00 pm Basketball (W) TheW.TV
6:30 pm Softball Mountain West Network
7:00 pm Basketball (M) Patriot League Network
7:00 pm Basketball (M) Patriot League Network
7:00 pm Basketball (M) Patriot League Network
7:00 pm Basketball (M) Patriot League Network
9:00 pm Basketball (W) TheW.TV
9:00 pm Softball Mountain West Network
9:00 pm Basketball (W) Mountain West Network
11:00 pm Basketball (W) TheW.TV
Friday, March 3, 2017
TimeET Title Category Network
1:30 pm Softball Mountain West Network
3:00 pm Basketball (W) TheW.TV
3:30 pm Softball Mountain West Network
4:00 pm Baseball Mountain West Network
4:00 pm Tennis (W) Mountain West Network
5:00 pm Basketball (W) TheW.TV
5:00 pm Baseball TheW.TV
5:30 pm Softball Mountain West Network
6:30 pm Softball TheW.TV
8:45 pm Softball TheW.TV
9:00 pm Basketball (W) Mountain West Network
9:00 pm Baseball TheW.TV
9:00 pm Basketball (M) TheW.TV
9:00 pm Basketball (W) Mountain West Network
9:00 pm Basketball (W) Mountain West Network
9:30 pm Basketball (W) Mountain West Network
10:00 pm Basketball (W) Mountain West Network

Popular Posts

  • College Basketball
  • February 20, 2017
  • Jeff Bartl

Livin’ B1G: Pursuit Of The Double Bye

Earning a double bye in the Big Ten tournament likely would lock up an NCAA Tournament berth for a bubble team. We examine which squads need it most and delve into the weekend action in this edition of Livin' B1G.

  • College Football
  • February 16, 2017
  • Robert Judin

Hey Judes: LSU Getting Back On Track With 2018 Recruiting Class

This week's edition of Hey Judes analyzes some hidden gems in the 2018 recruiting class, as they've fallen victim to the three-star curse. Plus, LSU appears to be getting back on track after a brief stumble.