Best College Baseball Players Ever

The 25 Best College Baseball Players In History

Some of the greatest players in baseball history first made a name for themselves in college.

Here are the 25 best college baseball players in history.

25. Tom Seaver: USC

Tom Seaver spent one season at USC after starting his college career at Fresno City College.

He dominated hitters for the Trojans in 1965.

Seaver went on to win 311 games and three Cy Young Awards.

24. Reggie Jackson: Arizona State

Reggie Jackson went to Arizona State on a football scholarship but became a baseball star.

He was an All-American as a sophomore in 1966.

The Kansas City Athletics took him second overall in the 1966 MLB Draft.

23. Barry Larkin: Michigan

Barry Larkin was recruited to Michigan to play football by Bo Schembechler.

He chose baseball instead and was named Big Ten Player of the Year twice.

Larkin went on to a Hall of Fame career with the Cincinnati Reds.

22. Jered Weaver: Long Beach State

Jered Weaver went 15-1 for Long Beach State in 2004.

He won the Golden Spikes Award as the best amateur player in the country.

Weaver later won 150 games with the Angels.

21. Mark McGwire: USC

Mark McGwire started his USC career as a pitcher.

He switched to first base and hit 32 home runs in 1984, a school record.

He went on to hit 583 home runs in the majors.

20. Roger Clemens: Texas

Roger Clemens transferred to Texas from San Jacinto Junior College.

He pitched the clinching game of the 1983 College World Series.

Clemens went on to win seven Cy Young Awards.

19. Mark Kotsay: Cal State Fullerton

Mark Kotsay was a star outfielder and closer at Cal State Fullerton.

He was named Most Outstanding Player of the 1995 College World Series as the Titans won the title.

Kotsay won the Golden Spikes Award that same year.

18. Jason Varitek: Georgia Tech

Jason Varitek was a three-time All-American catcher at Georgia Tech.

He won the Golden Spikes Award in 1994 and led the Yellow Jackets to the College World Series final.

Georgia Tech retired his number.

17. Dylan Crews: LSU

Dylan Crews was one of the best hitters in SEC history.

He won the Golden Spikes Award in 2023 and led LSU to the national title.

The Washington Nationals took him second overall in the 2023 MLB Draft.

16. Ben McDonald: LSU

Ben McDonald was a 6-foot-7 right-hander who also played basketball at LSU.

He won the Golden Spikes Award in 1989.

The Baltimore Orioles took him first overall that summer.

15. David Price: Vanderbilt

David Price was the best pitcher in college baseball in 2007.

He won the Golden Spikes Award and helped make Vanderbilt a national power.

The Tampa Bay Rays took him first overall in the 2007 MLB Draft.

14. Brooks Kieschnick: Texas

Brooks Kieschnick was one of the best two-way players in college baseball history.

He was a star hitter and a starting pitcher for Texas and was a three-time All-American.

Kieschnick later played in the majors as both a hitter and a reliever.

13. Todd Helton: Tennessee

Todd Helton was a quarterback, a first baseman and a pitcher at Tennessee.

He won the Dick Howser Trophy in 1995 and set an SEC record with 47 straight scoreless innings.

Helton went on to a Hall of Fame career with the Colorado Rockies.

12. Mark Prior: USC

Mark Prior won the Golden Spikes Award in 2001 after striking out 202 batters.

He was considered one of the most polished college pitchers ever.

The Chicago Cubs took him second overall in the 2001 MLB Draft.

11. Paul Skenes: LSU

Paul Skenes transferred from Air Force to LSU and had one of the greatest seasons ever by a college pitcher.

He set the SEC record with 209 strikeouts in 2023 and was named Most Outstanding Player of the College World Series.

He was taken first overall in the 2023 MLB Draft and won National League Rookie of the Year in 2024.

10. Adley Rutschman: Oregon State

Adley Rutschman was named Most Outstanding Player of the 2018 College World Series as Oregon State won the title.

He won the Golden Spikes Award in 2019.

The Baltimore Orioles took him first overall that summer.

9. Dave Winfield: Minnesota

Dave Winfield was a star pitcher and outfielder at Minnesota and also played basketball for the Gophers.

He was named Most Outstanding Player of the 1973 College World Series.

He was drafted by teams in MLB, the NBA, the ABA and the NFL.

8. Will Clark: Mississippi State

Will Clark had one of the sweetest swings in college baseball history.

He won the Golden Spikes Award in 1985.

Clark and Rafael Palmeiro made Mississippi State one of the most dangerous lineups in the country.

7. Pete Incaviglia: Oklahoma State

Pete Incaviglia hit 48 home runs for Oklahoma State in 1985, still the NCAA single-season record.

He finished his college career with 100 home runs.

The Montreal Expos took him eighth overall in the 1985 MLB Draft.

6. Robin Ventura: Oklahoma State

Robin Ventura put together a 58-game hitting streak in 1987, which is still the NCAA record.

He won the Golden Spikes Award in 1988.

Ventura went on to win six Gold Gloves in the majors.

5. Stephen Strasburg: San Diego State

Stephen Strasburg

Stephen Strasburg went from an overweight freshman to the best pitcher in college baseball at San Diego State under Tony Gwynn.

In 2009, he struck out 23 batters in a game against Utah and won the Golden Spikes Award.

The Washington Nationals took him first overall that summer.

4. Dustin Pedroia: Arizona State

Dustin Pedroia

Dustin Pedroia was a three-year starter at shortstop for Arizona State.

He was an All-American and one of the best defensive infielders in the country.

Pedroia went on to win the AL MVP award and two World Series titles with the Boston Red Sox.

3. Kris Bryant: San Diego

Kris Bryant

Kris Bryant led the nation with 31 home runs in 2013.

He won the Golden Spikes Award that season.

Bryant went on to win National League Rookie of the Year and MVP and helped the Chicago Cubs win the 2016 World Series.

2. Buster Posey: Florida State

Alex Rodriguez

Buster Posey started his career at Florida State as a shortstop before moving behind the plate.

In 2008, he hit .463 and won the Golden Spikes Award. He even played all nine positions in one game.

Posey went on to win three World Series titles with the San Francisco Giants.

1. Barry Bonds: Arizona State

Barry Bonds

Barry Bonds was a star outfielder at Arizona State and was named an All-American in 1985.

He tied a College World Series record with seven straight hits in 1984.

Bonds went on to become MLB’s all-time home run leader.

Similar Posts