The 5 Biggest NFL Draft Busts

The 25 Biggest NFL Draft Busts

Every year, NFL teams hope they’ve found a franchise player in the first round. Sometimes, it goes horribly wrong.

Here are the 25 biggest NFL Draft busts of all time, and what they did in college before it all went wrong.

25. Andre Wadsworth (DE, Arizona Cardinals, 1998)

Andre Wadsworth was a dominant pass-rusher at Florida State.

The Cardinals took him third overall in 1998.

Knee injuries ended his career after just three seasons.

24. Cade McNown (QB, Chicago Bears, 1999)

Cade McNown was a star quarterback at UCLA and led the Bruins to a 20-game winning streak.

The Bears took him 12th overall in a loaded quarterback class.

He lasted just two seasons in Chicago.

23. Mike Williams (WR, Detroit Lions, 2005)

Mike Williams was a star receiver at USC before sitting out a season after a failed attempt to enter the NFL Draft early.

The Lions took him 10th overall, making him their third straight first-round receiver.

He was out of Detroit after two seasons, though he later had a comeback with Seattle.

22. Matt Leinart (QB, Arizona Cardinals, 2006)

Matt Leinart won a Heisman Trophy and two national titles at USC.

The Cardinals took him 10th overall in 2006.

He started just 18 games in his NFL career.

21. Steve Emtman (DE, Indianapolis Colts, 1992)

Steve Emtman was the most dominant defensive player in college football at Washington.

The Colts took him first overall in 1992.

Knee injuries derailed his career almost as soon as it started.

20. Rick Mirer (QB, Seattle Seahawks, 1993)

Rick Mirer was a star quarterback at Notre Dame and was compared to Joe Montana.

The Seahawks took him second overall in 1993.

He bounced around the league and never became a franchise quarterback.

19. Justin Blackmon (WR, Jacksonville Jaguars, 2012)

Justin Blackmon won the Biletnikoff Award twice at Oklahoma State.

The Jaguars took him fifth overall in 2012.

Off-field problems ended his career after just two seasons.

18. Dion Jordan (DE, Miami Dolphins, 2013)

Dion Jordan was a freakish athlete at Oregon.

The Dolphins traded up to take him third overall in 2013.

He had just three sacks for Miami and struggled with suspensions.

17. Johnny Manziel (QB, Cleveland Browns, 2014)

Johnny Manziel was one of the most exciting players in college football history at Texas A&M.

The Browns took him 22nd overall in 2014.

He lasted just two seasons in the NFL.

16. Vernon Gholston (DE, New York Jets, 2008)

Vernon Gholston had a huge final season at Ohio State and dominated the NFL Combine.

The Jets took him sixth overall in 2008.

He played three seasons and never recorded a single sack.

15. Lawrence Phillips (RB, St. Louis Rams, 1996)

Lawrence Phillips was one of the most talented running backs in the country at Nebraska.

The Rams took him sixth overall in 1996 despite off-field concerns.

He was released less than two years later.

14. Aundray Bruce (LB, Atlanta Falcons, 1988)

Aundray Bruce was a dominant pass-rusher at Auburn.

The Falcons took him first overall in 1988.

He never became a full-time starter and had just 32 sacks in 11 seasons.

13. Brian Bosworth (LB, Seattle Seahawks, 1987)

Brian Bosworth was a two-time Butkus Award winner at Oklahoma.

The Seahawks took him in the supplemental draft and gave him the biggest rookie contract in NFL history at the time.

He played just three seasons, and many fans remember him for getting run over by Bo Jackson.

12. Courtney Brown (DE, Cleveland Browns, 2000)

Courtney Brown set Penn State’s career sack record.

The Browns took him first overall in 2000.

Injuries limited him to 19 sacks in six seasons.

11. Trent Richardson (RB, Cleveland Browns, 2012)

Trent Richardson won two national titles at Alabama.

The Browns took him third overall in 2012 and traded him after just one season.

He averaged just 3.3 yards per carry in his NFL career.

10. Blair Thomas (RB, New York Jets, 1990)

Blair Thomas was a star running back at Penn State.

The Jets took him second overall in 1990.

He never ran for more than 728 yards in a season.

9. Heath Shuler (QB, Washington, 1994)

Heath Shuler finished second in the Heisman voting at Tennessee in 1993.

Washington took him third overall in 1994.

He threw more interceptions than touchdowns and was out of the league after four seasons.

8. David Carr (QB, Houston Texans, 2002)

David Carr put up huge numbers at Fresno State.

The expansion Texans took him first overall in 2002.

He was sacked an NFL-record 76 times as a rookie and never recovered.

7. Tim Couch (QB, Cleveland Browns, 1999)

Tim Couch was one of the most prolific passers in SEC history at Kentucky.

The expansion Browns took him first overall in 1999.

Injuries and a bad supporting cast ended his career after five seasons.

6. Akili Smith (QB, Cincinnati Bengals, 1999)

Akili Smith had one great season at Oregon.

The Bengals took him third overall in 1999.

He threw just five touchdown passes in his NFL career.

5. Ki-Jana Carter (RB, Cincinnati Bengals, 1995)

Ki-Jana Carter Cincinnati Bengals 1995

Ki-Jana Carter was the best running back in the country at Penn State in 1994.

The Bengals traded up to take him first overall in 1995.

He tore his ACL in his first preseason game and was never the same.

4. Charles Rogers (WR, Detroit Lions, 2003)

Charles Rogers Detroit Lions 2003

Charles Rogers won the Biletnikoff Award at Michigan State.

The Lions took him second overall in 2003.

He broke his collarbone twice and caught just 36 passes in his career.

3. Tony Mandarich (OT, Green Bay Packers, 1989)

Tony Mandarich Green Bay Packers 1989

Tony Mandarich was called the best offensive line prospect ever coming out of Michigan State.

The Packers took him second overall, ahead of Barry Sanders, Derrick Thomas and Deion Sanders.

He was out of Green Bay after three seasons.

2. Ryan Leaf (QB, San Diego Chargers, 1998)

Ryan Leaf San Diego Chargers 1998

Ryan Leaf led Washington State to the Rose Bowl and was a Heisman finalist.

The Chargers took him second overall, one pick after Peyton Manning.

He threw 14 touchdown passes and 36 interceptions in his NFL career.

1. JaMarcus Russell (QB, Oakland Raiders, 2007)

JaMarcus Russell Oakland Raiders 2007

JaMarcus Russell was the MVP of the Sugar Bowl after leading LSU past Notre Dame.

The Raiders took him first overall in 2007.

He held out as a rookie, struggled with his weight and work ethic, and was out of the league after three seasons.

Similar Posts