25 Biggest Underdog Wins in College Football History
There’s nothing like a shocking underdog win in college football. High-ranked teams set to roll over lower-tier schools sometimes get the shock of their lives.
Here are the 25 biggest underdog wins in college football history. Check out the list of schools that defied the odds to beat supposedly superior opponents.
25. Eastern Washington vs. Oregon State (2013)
Eastern Washington came into Corvallis as an FCS team facing a ranked Pac-12 opponent.
Vernon Adams threw for 411 yards and four touchdowns and ran for two more.
The Eagles won 49-46 in a shootout.
24. Liberty vs. Baylor (2017)
Liberty was still an FCS program when it traveled to Waco in 2017.
The Flames put up 48 points on the Bears.
Liberty won 48-45 on the same day Howard shocked UNLV.
23. Marshall vs. #8 Notre Dame (2022)
Marshall was in its first season in the Sun Belt when it visited South Bend.
The Thundering Herd controlled the game and won 26-21.
It was Marcus Freeman’s first home game as Notre Dame’s head coach.
22. Appalachian State vs. #6 Texas A&M (2022)
Texas A&M paid Appalachian State $1.5 million to come to College Station.
The Mountaineers held the Aggies to 186 yards and won 17-14.
Fifteen years after beating Michigan, App State did it again.
21. Central Michigan vs. Western Michigan (2000)
Western Michigan was one of the best teams in the MAC in 2000.
Central Michigan was a heavy underdog but beat its rival 21-17.
It’s still one of the biggest upsets in MAC history.
20. Idaho State vs. Nevada (2017)
FCS Idaho State traveled to Reno as a huge underdog.
The Bengals won 30-28.
It was one of the biggest upsets of a wild opening month of the 2017 season.
19. James Madison vs. #13 Virginia Tech (2010)
Virginia Tech had just lost a close game to Boise State to open the 2010 season.
FCS James Madison came to Blacksburg and won 21-16.
The Hokies went on to win the ACC title anyway.
18. Georgia Southern vs. Florida (2013)
FCS Georgia Southern ran the triple option against Florida in the Swamp.
The Eagles didn’t complete a single pass, but ran for 429 yards.
Georgia Southern won 26-20.
17. Louisiana-Monroe vs. Alabama (2007)
Nick Saban’s first season at Alabama hit a low point in November 2007.
Louisiana-Monroe came into Tuscaloosa and won 21-14.
It’s one of the lowest moments of Saban’s career, and he won the national title two years later.
16. Michigan vs. #2 Ohio State (2024)
Michigan was unranked and had already lost five games when it went to Columbus in 2024.
The Wolverines held Ohio State to 10 points and won 13-10 on a late field goal.
Ohio State went on to win the national title, but Michigan had now beaten the Buckeyes four straight times.
15. Kansas vs. Texas (2021)
Kansas had won just one game in 2021 when it went to Austin as a 31-point underdog.
The Jayhawks jumped out to a big lead and held on to win 57-56 in overtime on a two-point conversion.
It was Kansas’ first win in Austin since 1938.
14. Michigan State vs. #1 Ohio State (1998)
Ohio State was ranked No. 1 and looked like the best team in the country in 1998.
Michigan State came to Columbus and won 28-24.
The loss cost Ohio State a shot at the national title.
13. Vanderbilt vs. #1 Alabama (2024)
Vanderbilt had never beaten a No. 1 team in school history.
Diego Pavia led the Commodores to a 40-35 win over the Crimson Tide in Nashville.
Fans tore down the goalposts and carried them down the street.
12. Pittsburgh vs. #2 West Virginia (2007)
West Virginia needed one more win to reach the national title game in 2007.
Pittsburgh, which came in with a 4-7 record, held the Mountaineers to nine points.
Pitt won 13-9 in the Backyard Brawl.
11. Illinois vs. #6 Wisconsin (2019)
In 2019, the 6-0 Wisconsin Badgers took on the 2-4 Fighting Illini. That year, the Badgers had hopes of going to the Big Ten Championship and were favored by about 30 points.
Illinois didn’t get the memo. In the final seconds of the game, James McCourt hit a game-winning field goal.
Illinois won 24-23. It was one of the biggest wins in school history and dashed the Badgers’ title hopes.
10. Northern Illinois vs. #5 Notre Dame (2024)
Notre Dame was coming off a big win at Texas A&M and was expected to roll over Northern Illinois by four touchdowns.
The Huskies walked into South Bend and shocked the world with a late field goal.
Northern Illinois won 16-14. Notre Dame recovered to reach the national title game.
9. Temple vs. Virginia Tech (1998)
Temple was one of the worst programs in college football in the 1990s.
The Owls went to Blacksburg as a 35-point underdog and beat Virginia Tech 28-24.
It’s still one of the biggest upsets in Big East history.
8. Syracuse vs. Louisville (2007)
Louisville came into the 2007 season with high hopes after winning the Orange Bowl.
Syracuse was a 37-point underdog but went into Louisville and won 38-35.
The Cardinals’ season never recovered.
7. Oregon State vs. Washington (1985)
Washington was favored by 38 points at home against Oregon State.
The Beavers blocked a punt and recovered it in the end zone late in the game.
Oregon State won 21-20, which at the time was the biggest point-spread upset in history.
6. Texas State vs. Houston (2012)
Houston was coming off a 13-1 season, and Texas State was playing its first game as an FBS team.
The Bobcats were about 35-point underdogs, but they dominated the game.
Texas State won 30-13.
5. UTEP vs. #7 BYU (1985)
During the 1980s, BYU had a tough college football program and was the defending national champion. The No. 7 Cougars were expected to beat UTEP by 36 points.
At the time, UTEP was winless. Nobody had a second thought that BYU would lose this game.
UTEP shocked the world and beat BYU 23-16. It’s still considered the biggest win in program history.
4. Centre vs. Harvard (1921)
Harvard was one of the most dominant programs in college football in 1921.
Tiny Centre College from Danville, Kentucky, went to Cambridge and won 6-0 on a touchdown run by Bo McMillin.
Many historians still call it the greatest upset in college football history.
3. Appalachian State vs. #5 Michigan (2007)
Appalachian State was the two-time defending FCS champion, but nobody gave them a chance in the Big House.
The Mountaineers led late, and Corey Lynch blocked Michigan’s game-winning field goal attempt on the final play.
App State won 34-32 and became the first FCS team to beat a ranked FBS team.
2. Stanford vs. #2 USC (2007)
USC was riding a 35-game home winning streak, and Stanford was starting a backup quarterback who had never started a game.
Stanford was about a 40-point underdog, but Tavita Pritchard hit Mark Bradford for the go-ahead touchdown on fourth down late in the game.
Stanford won 24-23 in Jim Harbaugh’s first season as head coach.
1. Howard vs. UNLV (2017)
The UNLV Runnin’ Rebels were expected to beat the Howard Bison by a staggering 45 points. Howard was paid $600,000 to play the game.
However, instead of lying down, Howard decided to make some college sports history. Freshman quarterback Caylin Newton, the younger brother of Cam Newton, ran for the go-ahead touchdown late in the game.
Howard won 43-40 in the biggest point-spread upset in college football history.
